Do you want content like this delivered to your inbox?

Don't Check Your Columbus Home's Value Without Reading This First

Lee Ritchie

Meet Lee Ritchie, your trusted ally in the vibrant Columbus Metro Area real estate market...

Meet Lee Ritchie, your trusted ally in the vibrant Columbus Metro Area real estate market...

Jan 24 6 minutes read

People throughout the United States have begun relying on “Zestimates” as their one and only source for obtaining their home’s current value. Sadly, as pointed out by the mainstream media below, this information can often be drastically inaccurate.

In fact, in Ohio, the median error rate is 7.1%. This can absolutely raise some eyebrows when people enter in their home’s information for an automated home valuation and see the number that's spit back at them. 

To put this into perspective, the LA Times mentions that in San Francisco, California the median home value is near $1,008,000. With “Zestimates” being inaccurate at a rate of 11.6% (in this area), this equates to about $117,000. If you were a San Francisco Seller-- that's a potential $117,000 that would belong in your pocket rather than out the window. That number alone completely ruins the expectation that computers are able to provide you with the most accurate answer regarding the valuation of your home.

According to the LA Times, Zillow’s very own CEO Spencer Rascoff answered that they're "a good starting point" but that nationwide "Zestimates" have a "median error rate" of about 8%

What Mainstream Media is saying
Los Angeles Times:
Inaccurate Zillow 'Zestimate' a source of conflict over home prices
Realty Times:
Can You Trust Zillow's Home Price Zestimate? In a Word: No.
Washington Post: 
How accurate is Zillow’s Zestimate? Not very, says one Washington-area agent.
US News Real Estate: 
Why Home Value Estimate Tools Aren’t as Accurate as You Think

1. Basic Information Can Be Inaccurate

User inputted data contributes to the "Zestimate."  Information such as how many bedrooms, number of bathrooms, square footage of the home, and the lot size must be accurate! 

The more information Zillow already has about your home, the better. If it's a newly constructed property or a home that has just been inputted into Zillow for the first time, be CAREFUL!

Below is an image that a Zestimate user created after immense frustration from the inaccuracy of the very basic facts i.e. Year built, square feet, # bedrooms etc. 

     Source: Zillow Advice Thread

2. Mistakes or Omissions in Sales Prices or Property Tax Records Can Happen

This is a BIG one. Property tax records are a part of the home valuation process that should never be overlooked. Just like inaccurate basic information, inaccurate date of sale or past sale prices affect the perceived value of your home. See the image below for an example.

         Source: Seattle Bubble 

3. Upgrades and Unique Features that are Unaccounted for

To keep things simple... Zillow won't know what you don't tell Zillow

It's highly suggested to REPORT your home improvements or upgrades that you make to the property. Although you may view it as a simple, quick and easy fix, it could, in fact, affect your home's overall value when it comes time to sell your home. 

There is a misconception that if you happened to update your kitchen or remodel your interior, that doesn't necessarily equate to $100,000 more in value than what Zillow says. Be mindful that upgrades and additions to the home greatly depend on what other homes in your market are like. 

The home below had several updates that were unaccounted for therefore resulting in a 30.10% error.

Source: Homes Realty Group

4. Housing Turnover Rate

The turnover rate for the housing market is a simple one. The hotter the market (the more homes that are selling and the more information Zillow has about the homes in your area) the more accurate the Zestimate will be!

5. Major Changes to the Zillow Algorithm

If you are in the market to sell your home, the Zillow Algorithm is something you should pay  close attention to. Any adjustments to this formula can affect the value of your home. However, Zillow doesn't adjust their algorithm very often. According to, when Zillow's algorithm was adjusted, it brought the National average two points down from last year to a median error of 6%.

As proud members of the Columbus Metro Area who actually live here, work here and also sell homes here, we would be happy to send you a free report of exactly what your home is worth. 

When it comes to the value of your largest financial asset, relying on technology may be convenient, but the accuracy of your home's value matters!

Our proven track record

In 2016, our listings sold for 101% of list price (Columbus Board of Realtors average is 93%).  

As the #1 REMAX team in OHIO, we know how to get outstanding results for our clients. 

What is YOUR home worth?

Accuracy matters. Get a FREE custom report.

Click Here

Want your home's valuation from a human?

We'd be happy to prepare a custom report for you.

We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience and deliver our services. By continuing to visit this site, you agree to our use of cookies. More info